The Dilemma of Balancing Security and Liberty in Lebanese Counter-Terrorism Legislation: A Comparative Constitutional Reading

International terrorism is manifested in any serious act of violence, or threat thereof, committed by an individual, whether acting alone or in concert with others, and directed against persons, organizations, or places, with the aim of undermining friendly relations between states or coercing them into making various concessions. Nevertheless, it appears evident that powerful states are reluctant to embrace an impartial definition of transnational terrorism, leaving the term as a political label employed selectively to characterize undesirable acts carried out by their adversaries on the international stage. Against this background, this study examines the dilemma of striking a balance between security and liberty within Lebanese counter-terrorism legislation through a comparative constitutional analysis. It concludes that the Lebanese legislature has focused primarily on the security and financial dimensions of the phenomenon through Law No. 44/2015, with the aim of ensuring compliance with the standards and requirements of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF). At the same time, it has retained Law No. 19/1958, which is characterized by ambiguity and the absence of a precise definition of a terrorist act. This has resulted in security considerations being given precedence over constitutional safeguards. Accordingly, the study recommends the enactment of a comprehensive and unified law containing a clear definition of terrorism and subjecting exceptional measures to prior judicial review, with a view to restoring the balance between the requirements of protecting societal security and safeguarding the fundamental freedoms guaranteed by the Lebanese Constitution.

Keywords: Counter-terrorism, Balance, Security, Liberty, Lebanese constitutional system, Principle of Criminal Legality, Judicial review, International Standards

Research Language: English

How to cite:
ElQarar Journal for Peer-Reviewed Scientific Research, Vol. 12, Issue 34, Year (3), pp. 64-98.

Download Citation: Endnote/Zotero/Mendeley (RIS) BibTeX

⚖️ Conflict of Interest:

The author/authors declare no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this research.

💰 Funding:

This study did not receive any financial support or grant from any public, private, or non-profit entity.

References

Al-Asadi, Hana Ismail Ibrahim, (2015). *Al-irhab wa-ghasil al-amwal ka-ahad masadir tamwiluh (dirasah muqaranah)* [Terrorism and Money Laundering as a Source of Its Financing (Comparative Study)]. Manshurat Zain al-Huquqiyah.
Al-Isfahani, Nabih, (1975). “Mawqif al-jami’ah al-’Arabiyah min huquq al-insan” [The Position of the Arab League on Human Rights]. *Al-Siyasah al-Dawliyah*, 11(39).
Al-Khashn, Mohamed Abdel Muttalib, (2007). *Ta’rif al-irhab al-dawli bayna al-i’tibarat al-siyasiyah wa-al-i’tibarat al-mawdu’iyah* [Definition of International Terrorism: Between Political and Substantive Considerations]. Dar al-Jami’ah al-Jadidah.
Al-’Awji, Mustafa, (n.d.). *Huquq al-insan fi al-da’wa al-jaza’iyah ma’a muqaddimah fi huquq al-insan* [Human Rights in Criminal Proceedings with an Introduction to Human Rights]. Mu’assasat Nofal.
Eid, Mohamed Fathi, (1999). *Waqi’ al-irhab fi al-watan al-’Arabi* [The Reality of Terrorism in the Arab World]. Akademiyat Nayif al-’Arabiyah lil-’Ulum al-Amnīyah, Markaz al-Dirasat wa-al-Buhuth.
Ghalioun, Burhan, (1993). *Al-Lajnah al-’Arabiyah, al-dawlah didd al-ummah* [The Arab Committee: The State against the Nation]. Markaz Dirasat al-Wahdah al-’Arabiyah.
Burdeau, G., (1986). «Les engagements internationaux de la France et les exigences de L’état de droit». *AFDI*.
Henkin, Pugh, Schachter & Smit, (1986). *International Law: Cases and Materials*, 2nd ed.
Kapitan, Tomis, (2002). “The Rhetoric of Terrorism and Its Consequences”. *Journal of Political and Military Sociology*, 3 (Summer).
Nguyen Quoc Dinh, (1975). «La jurisprudence française actuelle et le contrôle de la conformité des lois aux traités». *AFDI*.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Permitting copying, distribution, and reproduction of the work in any medium or format for any purpose, even commercially, provided the original work is properly attributed.